Current:Home > MyA Texas county removed 17 books from its libraries. An appeals court says eight must be returned.-InfoLens
A Texas county removed 17 books from its libraries. An appeals court says eight must be returned.
View Date:2024-12-23 16:34:36
NEW ORLEANS (AP) — Eight books dealing with subjects including racism and transgender issues must be returned to library shelves in a rural Texas county that had removed them in an ongoing book banning controversy, a divided panel of three federal appeals court judges ruled Thursday.
It was a partial victory for seven library patrons who sued numerous officials with the Llano County library system and the county government after 17 books were removed. In Thursday’s opinion from a three-judge panel of the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans, one judge voted to uphold a lower court order that the books should be returned. Another largely agreed but said nine of the books could stay off the shelves as the appeal plays out.
A third dissented entirely, meaning a majority supported returning eight books.
In March 2023, U.S. District Judge Robert Pitman ordered 17 books returned to Kingsland library shelves while a citizen lawsuit against book banning proceeded. The works ranged from children’s books to award-winning nonfiction, including “They Called Themselves the K.K.K: The Birth of an American Terrorist Group,” by Susan Campbell Bartoletti; and “It’s Perfectly Normal: Changing Bodies, Growing Up, Sex and Sexual Health,” by Robie Harris.
The ruling from Pitman, nominated to the federal court by former President Barack Obama, was on hold during the appeal. Thursday’s ruling was a preliminary injunction, and more court proceedings are likely.
The main opinion was by Judge Jacques Wiener, nominated to the court by former President George H. W. Bush. Wiener said the books were clearly removed at the behest of county officials who disagreed with the books’ messages.
“But a book may not be removed for the sole — or a substantial — reason that the decisionmaker does not wish patrons to be able to access the book’s viewpoint or message,” Wiener wrote.
Judge Leslie Southwick, a nominee of former President George W. Bush, agreed, partially. He argued that some of the removals might stand a court test as the case progresses, noting that some of the books dealt more with “juvenile, flatulent humor” than weightier subjects.
“I do not find those books were removed on the basis of a dislike for the ideas within them when it has not been shown the books contain any ideas with which to disagree,” Southwick wrote.
Judge Stuart Kyle Duncan, a nominee of former President Donald Trump, dissented fully. “The commission hanging in my office says ‘Judge,’ not ‘Librarian.’ ” Duncan wrote. “Imagine my surprise, then, to learn that my two esteemed colleagues have appointed themselves co-chairs of every public library board across the Fifth Circuit.”
The circuit covers federal courts in Mississippi, Louisiana and Texas.
veryGood! (69754)
Related
- Study finds Wisconsin voters approved a record number of school referenda
- Mother, boyfriend face more charges after her son’s remains found in Wisconsin woods
- There are 11 remaining college football unbeatens. Predicting when each will lose
- Ex-funeral home owner pleads guilty to assaulting police and journalists during Capitol riot
- Ariana Grande's Brunette Hair Transformation Is a Callback to Her Roots
- Alabama to execute man for killing 5 in what he says was a meth-fueled rampage
- 15-year-old Kansas football player’s death is blamed on heat
- Travis Barker's son Landon denies Diddy-themed birthday party: 'A bad situation'
- Mississippi woman pleads guilty to stealing Social Security funds
- Angel Reese says WNBA salary doesn't even pay rent: 'Living beyond my means!'
Ranking
- Kate Spade Outlet’s Early Black Friday Sale – Get a $259 Bag for $59 & More Epic Deals Starting at $25
- Booming buyouts: Average cost of firing college football coach continues to rise
- Niall Horan Details Final Moments With Liam Payne in Heartbreaking Tribute
- Canadian former Olympic snowboarder wanted in US drug trafficking case
- 'Bizarre:' Naked man arrested after found in crawl space of California woman's home
- Georgia state government cash reserves keep growing despite higher spending
- Prosecutors ask Massachusetts’ highest court to allow murder retrial for Karen Read
- A man has been charged with murder in connection with an Alabama shooting that left 4 dead
Recommendation
-
4 arrested in California car insurance scam: 'Clearly a human in a bear suit'
-
Parkland shooting judge criticizes shooter’s attorneys during talk to law students
-
WNBA Finals, Game 4: How to watch New York Liberty at Minnesota Lynx
-
LSU's Brian Kelly among college football coaches who left bonus money on the table
-
Bodyless head washes ashore on a South Florida beach
-
'Dune: Prophecy' cast, producers reveal how the HBO series expands on the films
-
BOC (Beautiful Ocean Coin) Grand Debut! IEO Launching Soon, A Revolutionary Blockchain Solution for Ocean Conservation
-
Prosecutors say father of Georgia shooting suspect knew son was obsessed with school shooters